Essays About Intellectual property and copyright

“Eili, Eili” as a “Traditional Yiddish Melody”

by Joshua Walden In 1918 the renowned St. Petersburg-trained violinist Toscha Seidel published a work for violin and piano titled “Eïli, Eïli.” The phrase “Traditional Yiddish Melody” appeared under the title, and the plaintive tune featured the augmented seconds and alternating duple and triple rhythms long associated with eastern European… Read More

Weighing In on Copyright

by John Philip Sousa Anent the “Blurred Lines” controversy, an excerpt from Sousa’s (possibly prescient) rant “The Menace of Mechanical Music,” Appleton’s Magazine 8 (1906), 278–84. And now a word on a detail of personal interest which has a right to be heard because it voices a claim for… Read More

Blurry

by Joanna Demers Justice Los Angeles County Courthouse The Williams v. Bridgeport [i.e., Bridgeport Music, Inc.]  decision, which orders “Blurred Lines”-co-writers Robin Thicke and Pharrell Williams to pay $7.4 million in damages to Marvin Gaye’s three children for… Read More

Blurred Lines, Ur-Lines, and Color Lines

by Robert Fink Nothing puts musicology in the headlines like a big, juicy verdict in a musical copyright case. And they don’t come much juicier than the 7.4 million dollar judgment handed down last week by a federal jury which, enabled by extensive musicological expert testimony, decided that Robin Thicke… Read More

LA-land

OK, we confess to finding the following, from this morning’s LA Times, to be the most perplexing (“confusing,” the students would say) passage about musicology we remember reading: Because laws when Gaye wrote the song allowed only the sheet music… Read More